Pizza is something that I take seriously. Really seriously. Like having mini-frozen-pizzas-from-New-Jersey-shipped-to-me-on-dry-ice-serious. Not kidding.
I’m now 3000 miles from away from said favorite spot, living in the Pacific Northwest for over a year and a half. And can you believe I have yet to find pizza even remotely comparable (any recommendations?)?
When I saw that this week’s Food Matters Project challenge was “No-Work Mostly Whole Wheat Pizza Dough (page 533)”, selected by our host, Niki from Salt & Pepper, to say I was excited would be an understatement! No work pizza dough that is mostly whole wheat? Really? So intriguing and exciting!
This is coming from someone whose house-building dreams include something like this -
PHOTO CREDIT: Authentic Italian Style Brick Pizza Ovens
Surprisingly, I guess, I had yet to dive into making yeast dough. Throw me in the kitchen with no recipe and a handful of ingredients and I’ll cook something marvelous, but flour, yeast and water? Scary!
My hope going into this challenge was to create a mostly whole wheat pizza dough that was simple to make, freeze and baked up into a thin, crispy and delicious crust.
I am happy to report that this is a great everyday mostly whole wheat dough. It is not however a thin, crispy dough, but it’s still really delicious and super easy!
The big news is that I am no longer scared of yeast dough, and if you are, you don’t need to be either!
I think it is safe to say that you will see some simple, everyday bread recipes happening over here in the near future, so stay tuned. Especially if my husband (hint) buys me this book for part of (notice the “part of…”) my Mother’s Day present next month.
Ok, now let’s talk toppings. I attempted to top this pizza dough as close to a Trenton Style Tomato Pie as I could. What the hell is a “Trenton Style Tomato Pie”? Right? Read this to find out. I couldn’t say it any better. If you are wondering which pizza place is worth flying their Pies across the country, it’s Delorenzo’s Tomato Pies in Trenton, New Jersey.
Scroll down on this page and read about why-this-pizza-is-so-frickin-unbelievable-I-want-to-buy-a-plane-ticket-right-now-amazing-good. Or click here for their website. Better yet, if you live in NY, PA or NJ or maybe even Delaware, head there now – but don’t you dare post of picture of yourself eating it on my Facebook Wall or I might have to ban you out of sheer jealousy!
Still want more Pizza? Click here to see what all of the other Food Matters Project members did with their dough! I have a feeling this week will be pretty interesting.
NOTES:
- I used King Arthur Flour.
- Whenever I am making a dish where tomatoes are the star of the show, I try to get fresh, ripe, local, organic tomatoes. If that isn’t possible (like now), my go to is San Marzano Tomatoes. If you aren’t familiar with them, read this.
- When it comes to pizza, don’t use part-skim cheese! Just use less. The taste difference is huge!! I started with a block of mozzarella (not buffalo or fresh mozzarella-just regular) and used a grater to quickly shred it by hand. It took less than a minute and is totally worth it. I divided up the remaining cheese into 2 and 3 ounce cubes and froze them for future pizzas.
- You may need more than 1.5 cups of water. If so, add additional water by the tablespoon as just a tiny bit makes a huge difference with the dough.

- 2 cups unbleached white whole wheat flour
- 1 cup unbleached all-purpose flour
- 1 teaspoon sea salt
- ½ teaspoon instant yeast
- 1½ cups water (see notes)

- 2 tablespoons olive oil, divided
- 6 ounces whole milk mozzarella, grated, divided
- 8 San Marzano whole peeled plum tomatoes, divided
- ½ teaspoon salt, divided
- ¼ teaspoon black pepper, divided
- pinch garlic powder
- pinch crushed red pepper (optional)
- In a large glass bowl mix flours, salt and yeast. Slowly add in water, staring with 1.5 cups until dough is relatively sticky and wet. If the dough is on the dry side, add more water (I used 1.75 cups which was a bit too much. I think the sweet spot is probably 1.5 cups + 1 to 2 tablespoons).

- Scrape down sides of bowl, cover with saran wrap, and place bowl in a warm spot. Let dough sit for 8 hours or up to 12 hours. The longer fermentation, the more complex the flavor is (I let mine sit for 8 hours).

- When rise is done, dust your hands with a little bit of all purpose flour and fold the dough over in the bowl a couple of times. Don’t use too much flour and use a gentle touch with the dough.

- Divide the dough into two.
- Preheat oven to 500F. Grab a baking sheet and measure ½ tablespoon of olive oil. Spread evenly with a pastry brush.

- Grab one half of the dough and gently stretch using your fingers. Be careful not to tear holes in the dough. Place onto baking sheet and continue stretching until desired thickness achieved. This is what size mine looks like.

- Pour an additional ½ tablespoon olive oil on top of dough and spread with pastry brush.

- Using 3 ounces of grated cheese, sprinkle about 2 ounces and set aside 1 ounce.

- Grab 4 of the whole, peeled tomatoes and use your hands to crush over the pizza (or use a knife on a cutting board). Squeeze them so the juice is evenly distributed. Finally, sprinkle ¼ teaspoon salt, ⅛ teaspoon black pepper, pinch garlic powder, pinch crushed red pepper flakes and remaining 1 ounce grated mozzarella.

- Place into oven and cook 12 to 14 minutes or until crust and cheese are golden. Allow to cool 2 to 3 minutes and cut into 4 slices. Serve immediately and Enjoy!







Everyday Maven is where whole foods meets weight watchers. Simple and delicious real food recipes for the home cook who wants to keep their food clean and their waistline trim! 
.jpg)












San Marzano tomatoes are the best. They are pricey but worth it. I didn’t know about them until I got some Ina Garten cookbooks and she’s all about them, so I gave ‘em a try and love ‘em! I only use them for special occassions though because my pockets feel the cost. LOL!
Margarita recently posted..Homemade Pizza with Swiss Chard Pesto and Toppings
They are $$$$! I only use them for things like Pizza or a quick Pasta Sauce. Otherwise, I use Pomi or Whole Foods 365. I would like to grow my own!
Great looking pizza!
Lexi recently posted..SKILLET GRILLED PIZZA
Thanks Lexi!
What a gorgeous pizza! It’s close to lunchtime and that is making me ravenous. To bad I don’t have any pizza here.
Mireya @myhealthyeatinghabits recently posted..Easy Mostly Whole Wheat Pizza Dough
Thanks so much
I hope you have a yummy lunch!
A person near and dear to my own heart. Nothing beats “Trenton Pies” and I am so lucky to still be living in the area to get some. There are a few other places around the county to get a great pie and I have learned to make my own too. Wish I could get my own pizza oven and I would be in heaven. I will have to try putting down the olive oil on the dough first. Looks awesome!! What helps Trenton Pies to be the best is the cheese goes down first then the tomato … most do it the other way. Love love love the blog.
Yes, exactly Linda!!!! Oh man, I am jealous that you can drive there! and Thanks
Haha! When you find the perfect thin crust recipe (whole wheat or not) PLEASE send it my way. Yours does look so much thinner than mine though. And the hand crushed tomatoes look divine!
Keely Marie recently posted..Whole Wheat “No-Work” Pizza
I will Keely! I am on a mission now – I want to perfect it
Alyssa, the first time I made my dough, I added too much water because I was kind of misguided by Bittman saying the dough should be relatively sticky and wet. So this time, I made my dough on the not-so-sticky-and-wet side and it was way better than the first time. It cooked perfectly and wasn’t underdone.
Good to know! I was hoping that is the case because I thought the taste was great. Now I just need to get it rolled out super thin and cook it till it’s crispy!
I have yet to try making a whole wheat pizza base – this recipe looks like a great place to start.
Amanda recently posted..Greek Mezés – Dolmades, Red Pepper Wrapped Haloumi and Spinach Patties
It is Amanda! I am excited to keep playing with it until I get it crispy
When you get that book I’d love to hear how it is. I’ve hinted about it as well- I’d love to make our own breads more often!
Evi recently posted..Food Matters Project #11: Apple & Smoked Cheese Whole Wheat Pizza
Will do Evi!
I love love love homemade pizza. I’ve only done it twice though because I hate messing with the dough! This pizza looks so great and I’m really excited to try this!!
Yes and this is so easy – I hope you try it!
Oh my gosh Alyssa you are too funny! I LOVE that you get those pizzas shipped to you. Haha. I’ve never had a Delorenzo’s pizza (though now I’m very intrigued), but yours looks pretty darn amazing!
Kristen @ Mind Your Bees and Trees recently posted..Feta, Artichoke, and Kalamata Olive Greek Pizza on the Easiest Whole-Wheat Pizza Crust—The Food Matters Project {Week 11}
If you make your way to the NE, you have to go!
I’m so jealous of how good yours looks! You’ve actually motivated me to try the recipe again, and not just stop on by Whole Foods for their dough
Do it Niki! I am going to make it again next and tweak it just a bit to see if I can perfect it! Great recipe choice
Your pizza looks so great! I’ve realized lately how much better quality cheese is than the lower fat stuff. I’m a big fan.
Cookie and Kate recently posted..Pesto Pizza with Fresh Arugula and Parmesan
Thanks Kate!
Well it may not be EXACTLY east coast/tri-state area pizza, but it still looks amazing! And yay for having a successful first yeast experience….here’s to many more!
Joanne recently posted..Recipe: Roasted Asparagus and Tomato Pasta Salad with Goat Cheese {eat.live.be.}
Thanks Joanne! I am excited about getting more into yeast dough
Hi Alyssa, Today I participated in an online chat with Mark Bittman. Someone in the chat posted this recipe for thin crust and I thought you might find it interesting.
http://www.pizzamaking.com/thincrust.php
Lexi recently posted..AMARANTH GREENS
Fantastic Lexi – thanks so much for thinking of me!
Can this be cooked on the grill? I’m not trying to get fancy but it sure is hot in my house during the summer,
Definitely but in a cast iron pan. You might need just a bit more oil so it doesn’t stick! Let me know how it comes out
This looks great! I’m afraid of yeast, too, but the no-knead has intrigued me. I think I’ll try this!
Tastefully Julie recently posted..Buffalo Chicken Grilled Pizza
If you have a pizza stone, the crust is even better!
Question – I accidentally bought whole wheat king arthur flour instead of white whole wheat. Will that still work or should I do 1.5 cups of each whole wheat and all-purpose instead of 2-1?? Thanks!!
It will be very dense and “wheaty”. I would probably do 2 cups all-purpose and 1 cup whole wheat!
Will do. Thanks!!