If you like my Comfort Food Zucchini Casserole, you are going to LOVE this Eggplant version!
It’s essentially the same recipe with a couple of modifications like swapping the Zucchini for Eggplant. I have to say, I like this version even better!
The Eggplant is so creamy, it melts into the casserole and it tastes even richer but, amazingly, it is still only 4 Points Plus for a huge piece. The only problem with this dish is how fast it disappears.
See below for instructions. The changes are simple; I highlight how to salt the eggplant to draw out the bitter liquid before cooking, switch to a yellow onion and using non-stick cooking spray instead of a Prepara mister to get the bread crumbs nice and brown at the end. Otherwise, it’s the same good ol’ casserole you already know and love!
NOTES:
- Like my Everyday Beef + Bean Chili, this recipe uses pre-prepared ‘tube-style’ polenta. If you aren’t familiar with this product, make sure to click on the Chili recipe and read about it in the Notes section.
- Unless you have homemade pasta sauce already in your freezer, save time and use your favorite jarred sauce. I like Trader Joe’s Rustico Pomodoro Pasta Sauce. If you use a different sauce, make sure to recalculate the Points Plus.
- To make this Vegan, omit the grated cheese and substitute nutritional yeast or Vegan Parm Substitute.
- 1 package pre-prepared polenta, sliced into thin rounds
- 1 jar Trader Joe’s Rustico Pomodoro Pasta Sauce
- handful basil leaves
- handful flat leaf parsley (mostly leaves)
- 1 small yellow onion
- 2 cloves garlic, peeled
- 1 large eggplant, sliced into ¼” rounds
- kosher salt
- fresh ground black pepper
- crushed red pepper flakes
- Italian seasoning
- ½ cup grated Parmesan cheese
- ¼ cup whole wheat bread crumbs
- non-stick cooking spray
- Clean eggplant and proceed to slice into ¼” rounds.

- Place eggplant rounds in a colander and generously sprinkle with kosher salt.

- Let eggplant sit in colander while you prep the remaining ingredients. *See Comfort Food Zucchini Casserole for remaining prep instructions* http://www.everydaymaven.com/2011/comfort-food-zucchini-casserole/

- Preheat your oven to 400F.
- Cover casserole with tin foil and bake covered for 40 minutes.
- At 40 minutes, pull Casserole out, remove tin foil and sprinkle bread crumbs on top. Lightly spray with non-stick cooking spray and put back into the oven for 5 additional minutes. If bread crumbs are not brown and crispy, switch oven to Broil for an additional 2 minutes of cooking time.
- Pull out of oven and let cool for at least 10 to 15 minutes before cutting.






Everyday Maven is where whole foods meets weight watchers. Simple and delicious real food recipes for the home cook who wants to keep their food clean and their waistline trim! 
.jpg)












You can eliminate the salting step by using Chinese eggplant which is never bitter. Cut on the bias if you want larger slices.
Great idea Norma – thanks!
Could you tell me what the calories in this dish is? It really looks amazing!
Hi Leslie, You could try Fit Day for a nutritional analysis. Thanks!
I think I have a lone eggplant tucked into the back of my produce drawer — and now I know what to make with it! This looks fantastic, Alysssa!
Faith recently posted..Grilling Virtual Cooking Class Recap
Sure Faith – this is great to have in the freezer too
I love eggplant and am always looking for new ways to prepare it. Never thought of combining it with polenta. Have bookmarked to try soon. Thanks!
Martha@ Simple Nourished Living recently posted..What’s the PointsPlus Value of Maamoul Lebanese Semolina Date Cookies?
You will love this Martha – especially because it’s such a generous serving for only 4 Points Plus! I also love Eggplant! I am posting a great eggplant salad next week so be sure to stop back
This looks MAGNIFICENT! Fat, comforting, and healthy…the perfect combination. Pinning! p.s…I made your Spicy Baked Tofu a couple of days ago and OMG YUM! I’ll probably post something in a week or so. Thanks!

Heather @girlichef recently posted..Roasting Garlic in preparation for National Garlic Day 2012 {event announcement}
Heather thank you so much!!! So glad you loved the tofu – can’t wait to see what you write about it
I make a low-fat eggplant parmigiana but this easy, polenta-centric way with aubergine looks great – and quick. I have never had a problem with bitter aubergines if I get firm ‘resh one, so maybe I have just been lucky. Any probs have come from buying them and then not using them within the week.
It is really quick! That is good to know and something I will pay attention to when I buy Eggplant!
Looks so comforting. Yum!!
Kiran @ KiranTarun.com recently posted..Whole-wheat mango hot cakes
Thanks – and easy!
Fantastic! I’ve never made eggplant that I’ve liked before I tried this recipe last night. It’s going into my repertoire. Thanks!
That is fabulous – I love hearing that Sandy!
I found your site on Food Blogs. Love your post and signed up for your feed. Can’t wait to learn more about you and your food.
CJ at Food Stories recently posted..Cheese Ball Day
Thanks CJ! I am going to go check out your blog now
I cant wait to try this. I have to get to TJ’s for the tube polenta. I wonder if I could somehow sub homemade polenta.. Do you have any ideas? Thanks!
Hi! You could definitely sub homemade polenta. After cooking, pour into a square container (spray with non-stick cooking spray so it’s easy to get out) and let cool completely. Just slide it out and slice down. Let me know how it comes out
This was a very good meal. We made it half zucchini and half eggplant to see what they were both like. We prefer the eggplant, but they’re both very good. It was a touch spicy for my wife so we’ll leave some red pepper off next time. We saved so many points on this great meal we even had garlic bread with it!
Thanks Scott – I have to say I like the eggplant better myself as well! Love that you had enough Points to enjoy garlic bread with it!!
I made this last night and it was so good that I blogged about it:
http://notrocketsciencenac.blogspot.com/2012/04/comfort-food-on-plan-eggplant-casserole.html
Thanks for sharing
Rachel recently posted..Comfort Food on Plan: Eggplant Casserole
Love that Rachel!
Yummy!! Do you think this could be made in the slow-cooker?
Kristen @ Mind Your Bees and Trees recently posted..Foodie Pen Pal Reveal Day—My Best Package Yet!
You know Kristen probably not. It would probably become very mushy since all the liquid would seep back into the dish whereas in the oven it evaporates out. If you try it, let me know!
Oh good point, Alyssa. Obviously I hadn’t thought about that! Thanks.
Kristen @ Mind Your Bees and Trees recently posted..Guest Post: Stepping Into A New Way of Living
Oh my Goodness. This was yummy!! Much much much better than the zucchini version and I had liked that one too. I was in heaven. The eggplant cooked and became creamy. I did add basil, parsley, mint to the onion mixture and did not measure but the herb mixture was so nnice too. Thanks for an awesome recipe!!
That is awesome! So glad you loved it – I am with you – the Eggplant is my FAV!
Do you think this would work with potatoes instead of polenta?
The texture will be very different. If you are going to try it, I suggest slicing the potatoes into very thin slices. Let me know how it comes out
This tastes great but i would bake the eggplant first next time. They were a little too raw for my taste
Hi Bettina,
I have made this casserole no less than 10 times and have never had the eggplant under-cooked. If you make it again, try cutting them a bit thinner and see if that works.
Thanks for responding. I made the zucchini version and it came out great. So good!! I love polenta.
Of course! I am making one of these for my freezer tomorrow since I have so much zucchini in the kitchen right now. So glad you liked it
do you know if this recipe can be frozen?
Hi Joan, Yes, it can!
Do you rinse & pat dry the eggplant after you’ve salted it? Do you freeze the casserole before or after you bake it?
Hi Janet, No, I did not rinse and pat dry and I have froze it both before baking and after. I prefer it frozen after cooking for easy reheating. Thanks!
I’m browsing your recipes and you’re making me hungry.
This looks so delish, one of my fave veggies!
Karista @Karista’s Kitchen recently posted..Slow Cooked Hawaiian Pork Roast with Coconut Rice
This is one of my favorites Karista! It really tastes so much more indulgent that it is – love that!
This sounds wonderful! It’s on the menu for this week, but one question….what size jar of pasta sauce?
thanks!!
Hi Dianne – I use one of those standard size glass jars of pasta sauce. They are usually 25 or 26 ounces. Have a great weekend!